Q&A: Popping a Cold One
From the comments on Monday's OA post, Gavin asks:
"I love the macro shots and your explanation, but since everyone is going to talk about those, I'll throw out a different question.
The shot through the window is also very successful. Did you do any gelling there, or is that all existing room light?"
Thank you, Gavin.
And actually that shot is lit entirely by flash. Or rather, flashes -- four, to be exact -- and every one is gelled. Diagram and walk-thru, inside.
__________
We were shooting each of the scientists and students working with the halophiles in this particular lab at the Center of Marine Biology in Baltimore.
I photographed Valerie working in a "refrigerated incubator," which is not a bad place to be in Baltimore in August.
I wanted to show temperature as a visual element, and the classic way to do that is to use cooled-down color temperature in your lights. This is where the CTB (color temperature blue) gels come in very handy, as not only do they come in relative strengths but are perfectly offset by the corresponding CTO (color temperature orange) gels.
So, to show temperature differential I would "blue" the inside of the fridge. As a contrasting color, and to make the blue stand out, I decided to use a corresponding warming gel on the outside.
This is where one of the Strobist gel packs can come in handy. They give you that set in quarter, half and full strength. Not exactly being a subtle guy, I went with full. But I could have nuanced this as much or as little as I wanted, were I one of yer more sophisticated types.
In addition to the warm vs. cool thing, I also had to shoot through the window without seeing my own reflection. This would be a little tricky as the window was small and I would also be lit by the exterior light.
So, I fired the (CTO'd) outside light from over my right shoulder, and shot diagonally through the window. Both of these served to kill my reflection in the glass. The outside light was also snooted, to put a little gradient in the door as the outside corners fell out of the beam.
Here is the diagram:

Inside, I wanted the whole room to be a contrasting, cool color. So I lit it with two speedlights with full CTB gels. Nothing fancy -- just sat them on the waist-high counter tops next to the near inside wall and bounced them off of the ceiling.
This got the effective light source (now, the ceiling) far enough away to light the room pretty evenly. I lit the room to about one stop down. Then I stuck inside flash #3 on top of the upper cabinet on the left and pointed it down, to add a light to Valerie.
Being as the room is already lit up to only one stop down from this little spot light, it is very subtle. But it does clean her up, light wise.
This light is also CTB'd, which keeps the full color of the interior consistent. But I did do a quick little cheat in post, lassoing Valerie's face and hands and warming them up a tad. Not all the way back to normal, but enough to sell the cold blue without Valerie looking too cadaverous.
We built the light front to back, one layer at a time. I shot at a 250th, to nuke the interior fluorescent lighting, and built the outside light up to a decent aperture. F/8 or /11 or something like that. Then my exposure was set and I just brought the interior lights up to match. No flash meter, no hard numbers. Just work fast and add salt to taste.
It took us about ten mins to set up and another three or four to shoot. The only stand involved was the one outside the door with the warmed up light. The rest of the flashes just balanced on stuff.
Quick and easy, really.
"I love the macro shots and your explanation, but since everyone is going to talk about those, I'll throw out a different question.
The shot through the window is also very successful. Did you do any gelling there, or is that all existing room light?"Thank you, Gavin.
And actually that shot is lit entirely by flash. Or rather, flashes -- four, to be exact -- and every one is gelled. Diagram and walk-thru, inside.
__________
We were shooting each of the scientists and students working with the halophiles in this particular lab at the Center of Marine Biology in Baltimore.I photographed Valerie working in a "refrigerated incubator," which is not a bad place to be in Baltimore in August.
I wanted to show temperature as a visual element, and the classic way to do that is to use cooled-down color temperature in your lights. This is where the CTB (color temperature blue) gels come in very handy, as not only do they come in relative strengths but are perfectly offset by the corresponding CTO (color temperature orange) gels.
So, to show temperature differential I would "blue" the inside of the fridge. As a contrasting color, and to make the blue stand out, I decided to use a corresponding warming gel on the outside.
This is where one of the Strobist gel packs can come in handy. They give you that set in quarter, half and full strength. Not exactly being a subtle guy, I went with full. But I could have nuanced this as much or as little as I wanted, were I one of yer more sophisticated types.
In addition to the warm vs. cool thing, I also had to shoot through the window without seeing my own reflection. This would be a little tricky as the window was small and I would also be lit by the exterior light.
So, I fired the (CTO'd) outside light from over my right shoulder, and shot diagonally through the window. Both of these served to kill my reflection in the glass. The outside light was also snooted, to put a little gradient in the door as the outside corners fell out of the beam.
Here is the diagram:

Inside, I wanted the whole room to be a contrasting, cool color. So I lit it with two speedlights with full CTB gels. Nothing fancy -- just sat them on the waist-high counter tops next to the near inside wall and bounced them off of the ceiling.
This got the effective light source (now, the ceiling) far enough away to light the room pretty evenly. I lit the room to about one stop down. Then I stuck inside flash #3 on top of the upper cabinet on the left and pointed it down, to add a light to Valerie.
Being as the room is already lit up to only one stop down from this little spot light, it is very subtle. But it does clean her up, light wise.
This light is also CTB'd, which keeps the full color of the interior consistent. But I did do a quick little cheat in post, lassoing Valerie's face and hands and warming them up a tad. Not all the way back to normal, but enough to sell the cold blue without Valerie looking too cadaverous.
We built the light front to back, one layer at a time. I shot at a 250th, to nuke the interior fluorescent lighting, and built the outside light up to a decent aperture. F/8 or /11 or something like that. Then my exposure was set and I just brought the interior lights up to match. No flash meter, no hard numbers. Just work fast and add salt to taste.
It took us about ten mins to set up and another three or four to shoot. The only stand involved was the one outside the door with the warmed up light. The rest of the flashes just balanced on stuff.
Quick and easy, really.
__________
New to Strobist, or lighting? Start here.
Now shipping, in DVD box set or download: Lighting in Layers
Connect: Discussion Threads | Reader Photos | Twitter







17 Comments:
Ha! The comment "just work fast and add salt to taste" just cracks me up!
...You know, cause its a assignment about halophiles?
As (almost) always a great post. Love the way of thinking and setting up. Would'nt it be easier hindside to snoot the 3rd flash with a cto to clean up instead of afterwards in PS?
cheers Vincent
Really a great discussion and description--inspiring. Was this all done via IR--no Pocketwizards or radio triggering? Thanks!
@dajagoe-
Oops, sorry did not include the trigger. The outside light was PW'd, as was one of the inside lights. Other two were SU-4-slaved.
@Vincent-
That would have warmed up the white lab coat (most efficient thing in that light's path) and lost that overall blue look I was going for. Really, I just split the diff, color-wise, on the face and hands in PS.
Cool stuff! If you don't have a lot of flashes and your not as fluent in photoshop, could you set your WB to incandescent and set on flash on Valerie with a cto and still use the snooted cto flash outside? Or would there be too much blue every where?
Cool stuff! If you don't have a lot of flashes and your not as fluent in photoshop, could you set your WB to incandescent and set on flash on Valerie with a cto and still use the snooted cto flash outside? Or would there be too much blue every where?
Even easier than the Lasso method would be to reopen the file, convert the skin tones to whatever color you want then slide the image under the first layer.
Then gently erase the top layer exposing the skin of the layer underneath.
I use this to correct teeth and turn them from yellow to near white. BTW, no one has perfectly white teeth - LOL!!
Terry Thomas...
the photographer
Atlanta, Georgia USA
www.TerryThomasPhotos.com
Finally a post that comes for the common people.
After some dozens of promotional posts for professional studios,here comes a simple tutorial as the strobist.com was a year ago...
Cheers
Between you and McNally this lighting stuff keeps on getting easier and easier to understand. Gotten "good enough" at it so I'll be leading a class on it this Saturday for some friends. I'm on second base and they're just getting to first. It'll take a little more time (and practice) to make it to home plate. Thanks for making all of us think a wee bit more about lighting.
really helpful stuff. i really appreciate it when you include the sketches. it has aided me greatly as i'm learning.
"I lit the room to about one stop down."
I was hoping to get clarification and insight into this. First the clarification - Do you mean that you lit one stop below the outside flash or 1 stop below the ambient light level?
Now for the insight - do you typically work with a single flash at a time? i.e. disable all other flashes until you have the desired affect of the one. Or did you go all-in?
Is this typically how you work and are there lighting scenarios where you've had to do it the other way around?
Heya David,
Thanks again for the 'enlightening' us on this shot!!
Since I'm canon and not Nikon, the "SU4's slaved" are manual triggers or are they TTL?
And speaking of Strobist gel packs, any info on how we cud get them over yonder in camel country - ie Dubai???
Thanks
Charles
@Uzet-
>>>"After some dozens of promotional posts for professional studios"
Erm... okay...
@error 454-
Search the word "shorthand" on this site to find the spot to get you up to speed.
Great post David, do you mind telling us what white balance you used for this shot?
@error - I think its 1 stop belo the outside flash level, since DH was shooting at max sync and killed the ambient. And I think DH (and Mcnally) already visualized what they were going to do to start with. The only thing he added was the SB to light up the scientist.
Wow, more answer than I ever dreamed. Thanks so much, David!
gfPHOTO
I have to admit, I wouldn't have thought to use the gels. I would have done it the hard way - shooting RAW and then making multiple files with different color temps and layering them.
Post a Comment
<< Home