Q&A: Lighting Multiple People with Glasses
"What if I were photographing an older couple for their 50th wedding anniversary and they both wear glasses? Of course there's always the natural light option, but if it has to be indoors with soft boxes or flash, what to do?"
First off, the original post on lighting for glasses in L101 was pretty brief and left some people with the impression that it only works for single-person portraits, which is not the case at all. Sorry about that.
Lighting glasses is all about the angles. To that end, here is our glasses poster guy from Lighting 101:
He is facing camera left, the key light is on camera right. No reflections at all. If I had lit him from camera left, there would be reflections. And to lose them, I would have had to walk that light so far up, or further to the left, he would have started to look bad long before I had clean glasses.
The way I have it lit above, there is still a reflection. But you can't see it, because It is only visible in a zone well to the left of my shooting position.
So what if he were two people? No worries at all. I'd just make sure both people were facing the opposite direction as the one my light was coming from. In Z9's hypothetical 50th anniversary photo, I'd stick hubby right behind wife's shoulder and solve it this way.
Works for large groups, too:
This group contains five people wearing glasses. They are all on the camera left side, facing camera right-ish. This was not by accident. The key light is on camera left, and it is big -- two stacked umbrellas. Still, no reflections because of the angle of attack.
(There is a wedding shooter in China who deals with this problem differently -- and ingeniously, IMO. Suffice to say, there's a group shot you want to arrive early for...)
Okay, so back our hypothetical two-person version of the single portrait above.
What we are doing here is called broad light, and it is not the best light for all faces. However, it is the best light for dealing with glasses. But just because the light is coming from camera right does not mean you have to light the whole camera right side of his face.
Here is our lighting diagram for the single-guy glasses shot, showing positioning for a second person. If I wanted a little more edge to the light, I could flag it from camera right, like this:
This would cut the light from wrapping around the camera right side of his face. It would be more interesting, a little more flattering -- and still no reflections.
I am working pretty close to the ambient in the portrait up top. But what if I wasn't? What if we had a deep shadow we needed to fill with a second light?
We could do that with some on-axis fill (ring light, umbrella behind me, etc.) a couple stops lower than the key. As long as I keep those glasses angled 20 degrees or so away from me (as they are in the photo) we would be fine.
In fact, combine the on-axis fill with the camera-right flag and you have some pretty cool-looking, glasses-friendly light.
In a pinch, I could also fill with a light bounced off of the ceiling. What would have been a problematic direction for our key would be much nicer for fill.
Anyway, just some added info for glasses photos. And as long as you know your angles, you'll never have a problem -- just a limited set of solutions.
But don't forget the potentially best solution of all: When you are about to shoot someone with glasses, ask them if they prefer to be photographed with their glasses or without. Lots of people prefer to lose them, and will thank you for asking.
But the important thing is that either way, you are good to go.
New to Strobist? Start here | Or jump right to Lighting 101
Connect w/Strobist readers via: Words | Photos
Got a question? Hit me on Twitter: @Strobist
Next live event: GPP PopUP Berlin (Oct. 29-30)